Orlando Goals: Mueller 62’
NYCFC Goals: Moralez 90+6
Orlando advances 5-4 on PKs.
New York City FC were dealt a heartbreaking penalty shootout defeat by Orlando City in the quarterfinals of the US Open Cup.
Maxi Moralez had equalized Chris Mueller’s 62nd minute opener in second half stoppage-time to take it to extra time and penalties where City were edged out in the second round of sudden death.
NYCFC reached the quarterfinals of the Open Cup for the first time thanks to victories over North Carolina FC and D.C. United and made a second trip to Orlando in 2019, following the MLS opening day draw.
Dome Torrent welcomed Héber back to the starting XI after the Brazilian’s hamstring injury, while Jesus Medina and Juan Pablo Torres also came back into the lineup.
Coming into this one on the back of Sunday’s 1-0 defeat to the Portland Timbers, NYCFC’s motivation to reach the semifinals of the U.S. Open Cup was evident from the first whistle.
After some early pressure from the Boys in Blue, it was Maxime Chanot who had the game’s first good opportunity with a header from a corner but Adam Grinwis made an incredible save to keep it out and Jesus Medina nodded the rebound over the crossbar.
City kept their foot to the floor but were unable to take advantage of some promising openings and Chris Mueller almost struck for the home team when his deflected strike wrongfooted Brad Stuver but whistled past the post.
From there, the Lions grew into the game and finished the first half the stronger of the two teams but NYC’s defense was solid and withstood the increased pressure they faced.
Newly-crowned June MLS Player of the Month Maxi Moralez almost sent his side in with a goal on the stroke of halftime but his shot from range just cleared the bar.
The game picked up where it left off after the break with the road team facing up to more Orlando pressure, with a Nani set-piece pinballing around the area before City could eventually clear.
Finally, the hosts did breakthrough when Nani’s cross found Mueller’s head on 62’ and Brad Stuver was beaten.
Dome’s reaction was immediate. With Torres forced off with an injury, Torrent changed the system to something resembling a 4-2-3-1, Bringing Keaton Parks into the midfield alongside Alex Ring and Ebenezer Ofori.
Taty Castellanos was next to enter the fray on 73’ as Héber was withdrawn on his return. After a hydration break and some final instructions from the Head Coach, City had 15 minutes remaining to keep their cup dreams alive.
Anton Tinnerholm was the final introduction from the bench and the Swede was closest to equalizing with one minute of regulation time remaining, but his header just cleared the crossbar and it looked like NYCFC had run out of time.
Step forward Maxi, who swept home from close range in the very last minute of injury-time to force wild celebrations and an extra 30 minutes.
Justin Haak came into the game as the additional substitute in the second half of extra time but it was Castellanos who almost secured City’s place in the last four with a curling effort which looked bound for the top corner until it was once again brilliantly saved by the home ‘keeper.
The teams couldn’t be separated in normal time so we went to penalties where Orlando took it in sudden death after Maxime Chanot saw his effort saved by Grinwis.
A heartbreaking way to go out but NYCFC will pick themselves up quick with the derby up next.
How We Lined Up
The Hudson River Derby is next, with NYCFC traveling to Red Bull Arena on Sunday. We’re back in the Bronx on July 26 when Sporting KC visit Yankee Stadium.